Business Details
34 Years
experience
Award-Winning Italian Restaurant & Catering in Staten Island
Established in 1992, Goodfellas Pizza has become Staten Island's premier destination for award-winning Italian cuisine. Our reputation as 4-time world champions in pizza-making reflects our unwavering commitment to quality and tradition. Specialising in brick oven-baked pizzas and house-made pasta, we combine fresh ingredients with time-honoured techniques to deliver exceptional dining experiences. Our catering services, available since 1993, have earned us recognition as Staten Island's Best Caters, serving both intimate gatherings and large-scale events.With a private event space accommodating various celebrations, we pride ourselves on creating memorable culinary experiences for every guest. Our team of seasoned professionals maintains rigorous standards in food preparation and customer service, ensuring consistency across our dine-in, takeout, and event catering operations. Backed by numerous five-star reviews praising our gourmet pizza crusts and attentive service, we continue to uphold our founding principles of quality and hospitality.
Services
Italian Catering
Private Events
Brick Oven Pizza
Online Reservations
Award-Winning Cuisine
House-Made Pasta
Event Catering
Dine-In Services
Takeaway Options
Wine Selection
Details
- Year established: 1992
Highlights and features
- We have over 30 years of experience in Italian cuisine
- Our team are 4-time world pizza championship winners
- We offer catering services for events of all sizes
- We provide private event spaces with customisable options
- Our menu features house-made pasta and traditional recipes
What people say
EXCELLENT spot for gourmet pizza
Best Pizza in New York
Service was just as good
Bread was the best I've had
Delicious and fresh food
Services
Italian Catering
Our comprehensive catering services transform any event into a memorable culinary experience. With over 30 years of expertise, we offer custom menus featuring our signature dishes, from classic Chicken Parmigiana to fresh seafood options. Our team handles everything from intimate gatherings to large-scale events, ensuring restaurant-quality food and professional service at your chosen venue.
Private Events
Our dedicated event space accommodates celebrations of all sizes, from corporate functions to family reunions. The venue features flexible seating arrangements, audio-visual capabilities, and full access to our award-winning menu. Our event coordinators work closely with clients to create tailored experiences, including holiday parties and special occasion celebrations, ensuring seamless execution from planning to completion.
Brick Oven Pizza
Our signature brick oven pizzas combine traditional Neapolitan techniques with modern innovation. Using a 900F brick oven, we create perfectly charred crusts with a variety of toppings, from classic Margherita to specialty creations. The menu includes gluten-free and cauliflower crust options, catering to diverse dietary preferences while maintaining the authentic pizza experience that earned us world championship recognition.
House-Made Pasta
Every pasta dish is crafted daily using traditional Italian methods. Our menu features house-made specialties like Penne Vodka with fresh prosciutto and Four Cheese Baked Rigatoni. From delicate ravioli to hearty meat sauces, each dish showcases our commitment to quality ingredients and authentic preparation techniques, offering both classic and contemporary interpretations of Italian pasta traditions.
Wine Selection
Our curated wine list complements Italian cuisine with carefully selected varietals from Italy and California. Featuring reds like Cabernet Sauvignon and Amarone, whites including Pinot Grigio and Chardonnay, and sparkling options such as Prosecco, our selection enhances every meal. By-the-glass options and full bottles cater to different preferences, with knowledgeable staff available to recommend perfect pairings with our menu items.
Questions
Do you offer catering services for special events?
Yes, we provide comprehensive catering services for events of all sizes, including custom menus and venue setup.
Can I make reservations for private parties?
We offer private event space bookings with flexible options for celebrations and corporate functions.
What makes your pizza unique?
Our brick oven pizzas use traditional techniques and high-quality ingredients, earning us multiple world championships.
Are there gluten-free options available?
Yes, we offer gluten-free pizza crusts and various menu items accommodating dietary restrictions.
What are your operating hours?
We serve Monday to Thursday 11:30 AM–10:00 PM, Friday & Saturday 11:30 AM–11:00 PM, and Sunday 11:30 AM–10:00 PM.
Do you have online ordering available?
Yes, our website provides convenient online ordering for takeout and delivery options.