Goodfellas Pizza

Established in 1992, we take great pride in being Staten Island's first brick oven pizza restaurant. Nestled in our new location at 4029 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, New York, we are proud to continue serving the community with our renowned pizzas, along with an extensive menu of Italian food, gourmet sandwiches, salads, pasta dishes, and seafood. We welcome guests from Staten Island, Brooklyn, and beyond to dine with us and experience our award-winning culinary delights.

A History of Passion and Excellence

The Original Goodfella's has a long-standing and passionate history of pizza making. Our love for pizza was ignited in childhood by eminent family-owned pizza restaurants like Patsies and Totonno's in Brooklyn. Our mission has always been to create nothing less than the best pizza possible, a mission that we have been honoured to accomplish in our first year of business.

Creator and Proprietor Scot Cosentino's dedication and passion culminated in the creation of the unique Vodka Pizza, which earned him the prestigious title of America's Best Pizza at the Jacob Javits Center, New York City International Hotel and Restaurant show. Since then, The Original Goodfella's has garnered a plethora of awards for our distinct and sumptuous gourmet pizzas, and have been featured on numerous TV and print platforms, as well as serving politicians, celebrities, and a host of local fans.

Our Secret to Success

The Original Goodfella's prides itself on using only the finest ingredients to create our acclaimed artisanal pizzas. Fresh mozzarella, imported San Marzano tomatoes, extra-virgin olive oil, and gourmet sauces all combine in an old-world cooking tradition in our real wood-fired brick oven at 800 degrees, resulting in a flavour that cannot be replicated.

Our diverse menu extends beyond our famous pizzas. We also offer a full bar, Italian dishes prepared to order, a pleasant wine list with homemade sangria, sandwich platters, and catering packages for any occasion. Our world-renowned pizzas and Italian food have led us to cater on the famed Presidential Yacht, and we look forward to participating in your special occasions with our catering services, as well as simply serving you a memorable dining experience in-restaurant.

Join Us at The Original Goodfella's

The Original Goodfella's team cordially invites you to join us in our new location for the finest Italian and pizza dining that Staten Island has to offer. Our friendly staff, unparalleled service, and commitment to using the highest-quality ingredients in all of our food promises a genuinely delightful dining experience. We are looking forward to serving our community for generations to come.